The New York Giants’ Strategic Quarterback Dilemma

The New York Giants had already been contemplating their quarterback alternatives, even before Daniel Jones’ hefty $23 million injury guarantee for the 2025 season could potentially become a problem.

Giants’ Consideration for a New QB

In an episode of “Hard Knocks” on HBO during the offseason, Giants’ General Manager, Joe Schoen, and head coach, Brian Daboll, were captured in a discussion about potential quarterbacks. Schoen mentioned Jayden Daniels, the LSU quarterback who bagged the Heisman Trophy, questioning if they had seen enough of Daniels to contemplate trading up for him. Daboll’s response was affirmative.

However, their plan of securing a higher draft pick didn’t materialize, and the Washington Commanders took the second spot, drafting Daniels as their future quarterback. The Giants are now set to face Daniels in Washington in their upcoming match.

The Tricky Injury Guarantee

Jones’ $23 million injury guarantee for 2025 becomes fully guaranteed if he gets injured and can’t pass a physical in the offseason. Other NFL teams have previously benched their quarterbacks to sidestep activating injury guarantees. This tactic was employed by the Denver Broncos in the last season when they benched Russell Wilson, fearing a potential injury could activate a $37 million guarantee for 2024.

Similar strategic moves were made by the Raiders last season with Jimmy Garoppolo and by the Colts in 2022 with Matt Ryan. These were all attempts to avoid additional financial commitments due to potential injuries.

Jones’ Performance and Future

As the current season is still in its early stages, the Giants have not yet reached a decision-making point regarding Jones. However, if Jones’ performance doesn’t improve – he has only thrown two touchdown passes in his last eight games – the Giants may be forced to make a tough call.

Jones had a disappointing performance in the previous Sunday’s 28-6 home defeat to the Vikings, throwing two interceptions and completing just over half of his passes. The Giants’ record stands at 1-6 in the seven games Jones has started since signing his four-year, $160 million contract.

Despite Jones’ rough start, Coach Daboll remains supportive of him as the Giants’ starting quarterback. Jones, maintaining a positive mindset, expressed confidence in his abilities and anticipation for the upcoming Sunday game.